Discovering New York City: The Cast Iron Architecture of SoHo

Cast iron blog 3

Discovering New York City: The Cast Iron Architecture of SoHo

After 17 years of wandering the streets of New York City, I’ve come to a funny realization: I still know next to nothing about its artistic, historic, and architectural treasures. Despite my countless strolls past iconic landmarks and world-famous museums, I’m as clueless as a tourist who just stepped off the ferry.

Sure, I’ve walked by the Met more times than I can count, but don’t ask me to tell you anything about its collections. As for historic sites, I could pass Alexander Hamilton’s house a hundred times and still think, “Wow, what a fancy little building,” before moving on to hunt for a good bagel.

And let’s not even get started on architecture. I can recognize the Empire State Building, of course, but once you ask me about Art Deco versus Beaux-Arts, my eyes glaze over. I might confidently point to the Chrysler Building and call it “that shiny one with the cool spire,” but beyond that, I’m hopeless.

Honestly, I realized at some point that New York City was like an intricate art exhibit that I was perpetually speed-walking through without pausing to read the plaques. So, with more time on my hands, I decided to start truly discovering New York City.

One of my recent discoveries was a tour with the Municipal Art Society of New York City to explore the cast iron architecture of SoHo, and it was fantastic. Here are some of my observations.

The oldest buildings in NYC are still standing on Canal Street, including a residential building and the Arnold Constable department store, built in 1856 and extended in 1862. (Canal Street was an actual canal back in the day!)

The Haughwout Store was a pioneering building in the use of cast iron as a structural element rather than just for repairs. It became one of the most renowned examples of architectural ironwork. As the New-York Daily Tribune noted in March 1857, “Another palace opened on Broadway: E.V. Haughwout & Co. opened their magnificent new establishment at the corner of Broadway and Broome Street last evening to the public facades in the city…”

That era marked the intersection of plaster architecture and the Industrial Revolution. Developers and architects quickly realized that cast iron was a game-changer: it was cheap, fast to produce, and fire-resistant. Mass production and pre-fabrication allowed for the quick creation of replicas, particularly of Italian Renaissance buildings and elements. For instance, the design of the Haughwout Store borrows elements from St. Mark’s Library in Venice.

The low cost was a major draw—there was no need for an army of sculptors, just molds. Plus, styles could be easily changed by re-casting molds. Since cast iron was stronger than bricks, buildings could have much larger windows, which wasn’t possible with brick structures. Taking this further, developers and architects realized that cast iron allowed for intricate designs that were impossible with brick or stone, such as the arches in the Haughwout Store

Over time, cast iron elements began to be combined with bricks and stone, creating what are known as “hybrid buildings.” A great example of this is the Mechanics & Traders Bank, built in 1885 at 486 Broadway. This building showcases the innovative use of cast iron alongside traditional materials, blending strength and intricate design with the classic appeal of brick and stone.

Architects also began incorporating cast iron fire escapes into the design of brick buildings, as well as using cast iron for balconies and columns. This integration not only enhanced the aesthetic appeal but also provided practical benefits, such as increased fire safety and structural strength.

Of course, the downside of cast iron was its tendency to rust, leading to peeling paint and structural issues. This required frequent repainting to prevent and stop rusting. Eventually, the invention of a non-rusting alloy—steel—marked the beginning of the end for cast iron architecture. Fortunately, the beautiful and historic cast iron buildings still line West Broadway in SoHo.

Interestingly, the street running parallel to West Broadway in SoHo was once a red-light district. Originally a street with light industry, it fell on hard times during the Great Depression, allowing the red-light business to take over. Later, the street was “recycled” to welcome artists, and some buildings still carry the monogram A.I.R. for Artists-In-Residence. 

West Broadway in SoHo continues to be a vibrant hub for galleries, showcasing the rich architectural history of New York. It’s truly a wonderful part of the city. There are so many other neighborhoods, each with its own unique character and stories. I’m excited to keep exploring them and learning from the experts and native New Yorkers. I’d love to hear about your experiences and any suggestions you might have!